Table of Contents
Cylinder Jamming with .357 Ammo:
- Problem: Users have reported intermittent cylinder, trigger, and hammer jams when firing .357 Magnum rounds.
- Possible Fix: Investigate the possibility of a short cylinder causing longer-than-normal .357 rounds to bind on the forcing cone. Some users have successfully addressed this by carefully filing the forcing cone, allowing smoother rotation.
Inconsistent Performance with Ammo Types:
- Problem: The revolver seems to function well with .38 special ammo but encounters issues with .357 Magnum rounds.
- Possible Fix: Consider the ammunition being used. In some cases, the specific bullet type, weight, or overall length may contribute to the problems. Experimenting with various .357 Magnum loads or using alternative bullet types might yield more consistent results.
Cylinder Gap and End Shake Issues:
- Problem: Users have reported concerns about cylinder gap and end shake, with observations of the cylinder moving forward during firing.
- Possible Fix: Use feeler gauges to measure the cylinder gap and end shake. If excessive end shake is detected, shimming with thin washers or spacers might alleviate the issue. Alternatively, consulting a gunsmith for a professional assessment and adjustment could be considered.
DIY Fixes and Community Insights:
- Problem: Some users have attempted DIY fixes, such as filing the forcing cone, leading to varied outcomes and community debates.
- Possible Fix: Exercise caution when attempting DIY fixes. While filing the forcing cone has worked for some, it may have unintended consequences. Seeking advice from knowledgeable firearm communities, such as online forums, can provide insights into potential fixes and their success rates.
Seeking Professional Assistance:
- Problem: Limited budget constraints may hinder users from seeking professional help.
- Possible Fix: While professional assistance, such as consulting a gunsmith or contacting the manufacturer, EAA, is recommended, users with financial constraints may need to weigh the costs and benefits. Saving up for professional assistance or exploring affordable alternatives may be necessary for a lasting solution.
EAA Windicator vs. Taurus 605
Discussion on selecting a compact, versatile firearm for elk season, woods carry, and general purposes. Focus on EAA Windicator (2" barrel, 6 rounds, full grip) and Taurus 605 (2" barrel, 5 rounds, stubby grip).
Taurus Reputation:
- Mixed opinions on Taurus, with some expressing satisfaction and others cautioning against it.
- Recommendations to avoid "cheap" or "junk" firearms.
EAA Windicator:
- Mixed reviews, with some users reporting satisfaction, while others consider it "junk."
- Positive feedback on durability and performance after abuse.
Concerns About Taurus:
- Discussions about Taurus' hit-or-miss reputation, potential issues, and improvements post-2017.
- Mention of Taurus' discontinued lifetime warranty and the impact on customer perception.
Importance of Trigger Quality:
- Emphasis on the significance of a quality trigger in the shooting experience.
- Recommendations for S&W and Ruger triggers, with a nod to the importance of spring work.
Consideration of Resale Value:
- Discussion on the resale value of firearms, particularly emphasizing the potential value retention of S&W and Ruger.
User Experiences:
- Sharing positive experiences with Taurus revolvers, including reliability and durability.
- Mention of potential issues like the nub on the transfer bar breaking off.
Alternatives to Consider:
- Suggestions for alternative brands like Ruger and Smith & Wesson, with a focus on reputable options.
- Warning against settling for a subpar firearm when quality alternatives are available.
- Suggestions for specific models like Ruger SP101 and S&W Model 64.
Conclusion
Consensus toward investing in higher-quality revolvers from reputable manufacturers. Overall recommendation for thorough research, consideration of alternatives, and avoiding compromise on firearm quality.
